Annotated Games: 4 players, version 0.1

This game was played during the game testing of Peoples - Civilizations. The players tried different strategies to assess how balanced they were.

1. Rome (red, aggressive): Expand, attack and conquer neighbors.
2. Babylonia (yellow, peaceful): Build cities and trade with neighbors.
3. Egypt (green, cultural): Spread monuments over the world.
4. Olmec (blue, economic): Build a strong economy.

Starting positions

The starting continents are by default separate but that may soon change. The Egyptians start on the smallest continent so we'll see how that affects their gameplay. The Olmecs have a future resource (coal) nearby, which may promote their industrious strategy later on.

Round 1

The game starts with a special round where 1 of the 2 starting tribes is moved, revealing a new region, and a neutral tribe placed in the continent. The Romans move to a commodity area and, since their continent now exceeds 2 areas, must reroll until they discover an area already in play. This happens to be the Olmec continent. They place their neutral tribe in a food area with the intention of taking advantage of it with military force. The Babylonians move to a food area. Since their continent doesn't exceed 2 regions yet, it may remain unconnected to other areas in play and the die roll add a sea region to it. They place their neutral tribe further away so it won't interfere with its city building plans. The Egyptians move to a luxury area. Their continent gets connected to a southern polar region and they keep their neutral nearby, at a commodity, with the intention of converting it later on. The largest Olmec-Roman distance remains 4 so any region may be added to it. However, it happens to become a northern polar region and when placed there, it also happens that the continent gets connected to the Egyptian continent. Three player continents have now found their place on the world map.

Round 2-4

All civilizations produce 1 food with their 1st tribe. With their 2nd tribe, the Romans and the Olmecs produce 1 commodity to spend on development, the Babylonians produce a 2nd food, and the Egyptians 1 luxury to spend on advances. We already see the different strategic paths.

• Romans:
  2. Produce 1 cattle
  3. Produce 1 timber
  4. Revolution: Feed 2 tribes, save 1 timber
• Babylonians:
2. Produce 1 grain
3. Produce 1 shellfish
4. Revolution: Feed 2 tribes, save 1 grain
• Egyptians:
2. Produce 1 poultry
3. Produce 1 wine
4. Revolution: Feed 2 tribes, save 1 wine
• Olmecs:
2. Produce 1 pulses
3. Produce 1 clay
4. Revolution: Feed 2 tribes, save 1 clay

Round 5-7

The Romans and the Olmecs buy development cards; Slavery and Farming respectively. The Romans are stronger than the Olmecs but an early war would be a waste of time. The Egyptians plan for both culture and religion to boost their production while the Babylonians grow for quicker production.

• Romans:
  5. Produce 1 cattle
  6. Produce 1 timber
  7. Revolution: Feed 2 tribes, buy Slavery (-2 timber)
• Babylonians:
5. Produce 1 grain
6. Produce 1 shellfish
7. Revolution: Feed 2 tribes, grow 1 tribe, save 1 grain
• Egyptians:
5. Produce 1 poultry
6. Spread culture (Culture 0)
7. Revolution: Feed 2 tribes, save 1 wine, reset (Culture 1)
• Olmecs:
5. Produce 1 pulses
6. Produce 1 clay
7. Revolution: Feed 2 tribes, buy Farming (-2 clay)

Round 8-10

We now see the different strategic patterns. The Romans use their Slavery card to enslave the neutral tribe and immediately use the plundered grain to grow. The Babylonians found their town and also grow a 4th tribe. They have no development or advance yet but will now produce at a higher rate. The Egyptians are still on 2 tribes but can soon look forward to a +1 bonus for both development and advance investments. The Olmecs have 3 tribes and is close to a 2nd development card but will they withstand the Romans if they attack?

The Roman and Olmec growth also reveals 2 new regions but mainly sea areas, making their clash more imminent. The Babylonians exceed a distance of 4, forcing their continent to be connected and it happens to be the Roman continent, although the sea separates them.

• Romans:
  8. Produce 1 cattle
  9. Attack and enslave neutral tribe, plunder 1 grain
  10. Revolution: Feed 3 tribes, grow 1 tribe
• Babylonians:
8. Produce 1 shellfish
9. Found a town
10. Revolution: Feed 3 tribes, grow 1 tribe
• Egyptians:
8. Produce 1 poultry
9. Move to grain
10. Revolution: Feed 2 tribes, buy Religion 1 (-1 wine, Culture 0)
• Olmecs:
8. Produce 2 pulses
9. Produce 1 clay
10. Revolution: Feed 2 tribes, grow 1 tribe, save 1 clay

Round 11-15

The Romans focuses on growth and plan to advance against the Olmecs. However, with less tribes the Olmecs launch their Revolution 1 round earlier and invest in a commander (one time military action point) to defend against a Roman attack. The Romans decide to grow southwards instead to claim as much as possible of the shared continent. Meanwhile, the Babylonians invest in Farming to start growing (and pay only 1 commodity but to the Olmecs, since they were the first to discover it). The Egyptians find themselves isolated on a small land mass and focus on growth instead to prepare for spreading Religion.

• Romans:
  11. Produce 1 cattle
  12. Produce 1 grain
  13. Produce 1 fish
  14. Produce 1 timber
  15. Revolution: Feed 4 tribes, grow 1 tribe, save 1 timber
• Babylonians:
11. Produce 1 grain+1 timber (Civics 0)
12. Produce 1 shellfish
13. Produce 1 timber
14. Revolution: Feed 4 tribes, buy Farming (-1 timber to Olmecs)
15. Produce 2 grain+1 timber
• Egyptians:
11. Produce 1 poultry
12. Produce 1 grain
13. Revolution: Feed 2 tribes, grow 1 tribe
14. Produce 1 poultry
15. Produce 1 grain
• Olmecs:
11. Produce 2 pulses
12. Produce 1 clay
13. Trade 1 poultry for 1 fur
14. Get 1 timber from Babylonians, Revolution: Feed 3 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Herding (-1 timber, -1 clay), buy commander (-1 clay), save 1 fur
15. Produce 2 pulses

Round 16-21

The Romans focus on producing for growth and development and invest in Mining. The Babylonians invest in Law to be able to use Civics as Culture and vice versa. The Egyptians finally spread Religion and will soon see how well their Culture/Religion strategy pays off. The Olmecs' trade strategy pays off already this round as they now have access to 3 different luxuries.

• Romans:
  16. Produce 1 cattle
  17. Produce 1 grain
  18. Produce 1 fish
  19. Produce 1 timber
  20. Produce 1 wine
  21. Feed 5 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Mining (-2 timber), save 1 wine
• Babylonians:
16. Produce 1 shellfish
17. Produce 1 timber
18. Revolution: Feed 4 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Law (-2 timber)
19. Produce 2 grain+1 timber
20. Produce 1 shellfish
21. Produce 1 dyes
• Egyptians:
16. Produce 1 wine
17. Revolution: Feed 3 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Science (-1 wine, Culture 0)
18. Produce 1 poultry
19. Produce 1 grain
20. Get 1 fur from Olmecs, spread Religion (Religion 0)
21. Produce 1 clay
• Olmecs:
16. Produce 1 clay
17. Produce 2 poultry, trade 1 for tobacco
18. Produce 1 spices
19. Revolution: Feed 4 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Science 1 (-1 fur to Egyptians), save 1 tobacco, 1 clay
20. Produce 2 poultry
21. Produce 2 pulses

Round 22-28

The Romans no longer grow and prepare an attack by acquiring a commander. Note that the Olmecs have too many turns left to their next Revolution to prepare a defence. The Babylonians continue their settlement building strategy by using Law to found a city (allows them to pay with Civics and Culture). With both Culture and Religion, the Egyptians are now ready to expand and do so by acquiring Theism and converting the nearby neutral tribe. The Olmecs prepare 2 strategic paths by founding a town and investing in Sailing to sail to new land. However, the Roman imminent attack interrupt that and they hurry to produce along the border areas before they get plundered.

• Romans:
  22. Produce 1 cattle
  23. Produce 1 grain
  24. Produce 1 fish
  25. Produce 1 timber
  26. Produce 1 wine
  27. Produce 1 metal
  28. Revolution: Feed 6 tribes, buy 1 commander (-1 wine), buy Heroics (-1 timber, -1 metal)
• Babylonians:
22. Produce 1 timber
23. Revolution: Feed 5 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Sailing (-2 timber), buy Culture (-1 dyes to Egyptians)
24. Found city (Civics 0, Culture 0)
25. Produce 1 shellfish
26. Get 1 clay and 1 tobacco fro Olmecs produce 1 timber
27. Produce 2 pulses
28. Revolution: Feed 6 tribes, save 1 timber, 1 clay, 1 tobacco
• Egyptians:
22. Revolution: Feed 4 tribes, buy Herding (-1 clay to Olmecs), reset (Culture 1, Religion 1)
23. Get 1 dyes from Babylonians, produce 2 poultry
24. Produce 1 grain
25. Produce 1 wine
26. Produce 1 clay
27. Revolution: Feed 4 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Theism (-1 clay, Religion 0), buy Religion 2 (-1 fur, -1 wine, -1 dyes, Culture 0), reset (Culture 1, Religion 2), save 1 dyes
28. Convert neutral tribe from distance (Religion 0, Science 1)
• Olmecs:
22. Get 1 clay from Egyptians, produce 1 clay
23. Produce 2 poultry, trade 1 for fur
24. Produce 1 spices
25. Revolution: Feed 5 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Civics 1 (-1 tobacco to Babylonians), buy Sailing (-1 clay to Babylonians), save 1 clay, 1 poultry, 1 pulses
26. Found town
27. Produce 2 poultry
28. Produce 1 clay

Round 29-35

The Romans attack and enslave an Olmec tribe and reach 8 tribes. The Babylonians invest in Culture and, since they have Law, use 1 Civics and 1 Culture to fully produce from the newly founded city. They will now produce rapidly. The Egyptians fill the last productive space of their continent and invest in Navigation to find new land while also founding their first settlement. The Olmecs don't worry too much about the last tribe as they produce so much food elsewhere. They are also fortunate to find new land when sailing westwards and can look forward to further growth. Note that their town (2 tribes)+1 commander can only be attacked by a military strength of at least 3 so for the moment they're safe from further Roman aggression.

• Romans:
  29. Attack and enslave Olmec tribe, plunder 1 poultry (-1 commander), get 1 commander and 1 architect
  30. Produce 1 cattle
  31. Produce 1 grain
  32. Produce 1 fish
  33. Produce 1 timber
  34. Produce 1 metal
  35. Get 1 clay from Egyptians, Revolution: Feed 7 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Roads (-1 timber to Babylonians), buy Herding (-1 clay) save 1 wine, 1 metal
• Babylonians:
29. Produce 1 dyes, 1 timber, 2 grain (Culture 0, Civics 0)
30. Produce 2 pulses
31. Produce 1 timber
32. Produce 1 shellfish
33. Revolution: Feed 6 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Roads (-2 timber), save 1 shellfish, 1 clay, 1 timber, 1 dyes, 1 tobacco, reset (Culture 1, Civics 1)
34. Produce 1 dyes, 1 timber, 2 grain (Culture 0, Civics 0)
35. Produce 1 shellfish
• Egyptians:
29. Produce 1 fish
30. Produce 2 poultry
31. Produce 1 grain
32. Produce 1 clay
33. Produce 1 shellfish
34. Revolution: Feed 6 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Mining (-1 clay to Romans), save 1 poultry
35. Produce 1 metal
• Olmecs:
29. Produce 2 pulses
30. Move to new land (Science 0)
31. Revolution: Feed 5 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy 1 commander (-1 clay), save 1 poultry, 1 pulses, 1 clay, 1 fur
32. Produce 2 cattle, 1 spices
33. Produce 2 pulses
34. Produce 1 clay
35. Produce 2 poultry, trade 1 for tobacco

Round 36-44

The game now develops more rapidly as all civilizations reach Age 2 in a civilization trait. The Romans use their roads to produce twice in a luxury area so that they can invest in Military 2. They also get Sailing as "public domain", since it has been discovered by 3 civilizations. The Babylonians continue their grand city plans by investing in Civics 2 and founding a metropolis. The Egyptians seek new land instead of their crowded one but also increase their production through a town and Cults (more commodities around Religion). The Olmecs continue their economy strategy with Economy 2 to trade more each round.

• Romans:
  36. Produce metal
  37. Produce 2 poultry
  38. Produce wine
  39. Produce 2 cattle
  40. Produce metal
  41. Produce fur
  42. Produce fur
  43. Produce fish
  44. Get 1 fur from Olmecs, Revolution: Feed 8 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Military 2 (-2 fur, -1 wine), buy Civics (-1 wine), buy 1 commander (-1 timber), save 1 cattle, 1 metal, 1 fish
• Babylonians:
36. Produce 2 pulses
37. Produce 1 timber
38. Produce 1 tobacco
39. Revolution: Feed 7 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Civics 2 (-2 dyes, -1 tobacco), buy artist (-1 timber), buy architect (-1 timber), save 1 timber, 1 pulses, 1 shellfish
40. Found metropolis (Civics 0, Culture 0)
41. Produce 2 pulses
42. Produce 1 shellfish
43. Produce 1 timber
44. Get 1 dyes from Olmecs, move to new land
• Egyptians:
36. Produce 1 fish
37. Produce 2 poultry
38. Spread Religion (Religion 1)
39. Produce 1 wine
40. Produce 1 grain
41. Move to new land
42. Revolution: Feed 7 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Cults (-1 Metal, Religion 0), buy Sailing (-1 timber), save 1 poultry, 1 wine, 1 fur
43. Found town
44. Produce 2 metal
• Olmecs:
36. Produce 1 dyes
37. Revolution: Feed 6 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy 1 architect (-1 clay), buy Economy 2 (-1 dyes, -1 fur, -1 tobacco), save 1 cattle, 1 pulses, 1 poultry, 1 clay, 1 spices
38. Found city (Civics 0, -1 architect)
39. Produce 1 clay
40. Produce 2 poultry, trade for 1 fur and 1 tobacco (Economy 0)
41. Produce 1 dyes
42. Produce 2 pulses
43. Revolution: Feed 7 tribes, buy Civics 2 (-1 dyes to Babylonians, -1 tobacco), buy Military 1 (-1 fur to Romans), buy Roads (-1 clay), grow 1 tribe, save 1 spices
44. Produce 2 cattle, 1 clay, 1 spices

Round 45-53

The Romans attack the Babylonians but also found a town to consolidate their empire. Their aggressiveness triggers both the Babylonians and the Olmecs to invest in Military while continuing their exploration of new land. The still isolated Egyptians pursue their Culture/Religion strategy with level 2 in both as well as adding Monuments to their previously acquired Cults, hence getting both extra luxuries and extra commodities.

• Romans:
  45. Attack and enslave Babylonian (Military 0, -1 commander), get commander, scientist, plunder 1 timber
  46. Produce 1 fur
  47. Produce 2 cattle
  48. Produce 2 cattle
  49. Produce 1 wine
  50. Found town (-1 architect)
  51. Produce 1 metal
  52. Produce 2 poultry
  53. Revolution: Feed 10 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Gunpowder (-2 metal, -1 clay), buy Science (-1 fur), buy Civics (-1 wine), save 1 dyes, 1 timber
• Babylonians:
45. Revolution: Feed 7 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Military 1 (-1 dyes to Romans), buy 1 commander (-1 timber), save 1 pulses
46. Produce 1 dyes, 1 tobacco, 1 grain, spread Culture (-1 artist)
47. Produce 2 pulses
48. Move to new land
49. Produce 1 sugar
50. Feed 8 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy 1 commander (-1 timber), buy Culture 2 (-1 sugar to Egyptians, Culture 1), buy Military 2 (-1 dyes to Romans, -1 tobacco, Culture 0)
51. Get clay, fur from Olmecs, produce 1 dyes, 1 tobacco, 1 timber, 1 grain, (Civics 0, Culture 0)
52. Produce 2 pulses
53. Produce 1 shellfish
• Egyptians:
45. Produce 1 fish
46. Produce 2 poultry
47. Produce 1 clay
48. Produce 1 tobacco
49. Produce 1 shellfish
50. Get 1 sugar from Babylonians, Revolution: Feed 8 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Culture 2 (-1 wine, -1 tobacco, Culture 0), buy Monuments (-1 metal, Religion 0), buy Art (-1 clay, -1 Religion), save 1 fur, 1 metal, 1 wine, get Roads free
51. Produce 2 metal
52. Spread Culture
53. Produce 1 wine, 1 grain
• Olmecs:
45. Produce 1 clay
46. Produce 2 poultry, trade for 1 tobacco, 1 fur
47. Produce 1 dyes
48. Produce 2 pulses
49. Move to new land
50. Revolution: Feed 8 tribes, grow 1 tribe, buy Law (-1 clay to Babylonians), Civics 2 (-1 fur, -1 tobacco to Babylonians), buy 1 commander (-1 dyes), buy 1 architect (-1 spices), save 1 spices
51. Found city (Civics 0)
52. Produce 2 poultry, trade for 1 tobacco, 1 fur
53. Produce 1 clay

The game was halted here and resumed with more resources at start and during game.

P&P (PDF, A4)	P&P (PDF, US Letter)

Annotated games

• 4 players, version 0.3
• 4 players, version 0.2
• 4 players, version 0.1

If you like those game mechanisms, I can also recommend: